Latest from Piping / Pumping

Charlotte Pipe and Foundry Co.
Viega
Charlotte Pipe and Foundry
Screenshot 2023 10 30 125004
Screenshot 2023 10 30 125004
Screenshot 2023 10 30 125004
Screenshot 2023 10 30 125004
Screenshot 2023 10 30 125004
HPAC Engineering
F7 K7z6 Sb0 Aaa7 1
F7 K7z6 Sb0 Aaa7 1
F7 K7z6 Sb0 Aaa7 1
F7 K7z6 Sb0 Aaa7 1
F7 K7z6 Sb0 Aaa7 1
iStock
Istockphoto 1235495974 612x612
Istockphoto 1235495974 612x612
Istockphoto 1235495974 612x612
Istockphoto 1235495974 612x612
Istockphoto 1235495974 612x612

An Easy Fix

July 1, 2007
I received a call from a client who had been working with a contractor for several months to resolve a recurring problem with a recently installed air-handling

I received a call from a client who had been working with a contractor for several months to resolve a recurring problem with a recently installed air-handling unit. The unit had been dropping out on freezestat whenever the outside-air temperature dropped below freezing. After several attempts to find a solution, the contractor declared it a “design problem” and disavowed any further responsibility.

On the next below-freezing morning, I visited the site and noted that the elevation between the outlet of the steam coil and the inlet to the steam trap was less than detailed on our drawings. I suspected there might be a stratification problem caused by the coil's bottom row, which was water-logged and not draining properly. I took several temperature readings. To my surprise, the air temperature was uniform across the face of the coil. However, the air-temperature rise was less than half of what was specified. I checked the steam pressure at the inlet to the steam-control valve. It was 12 psig, which was reasonable. I checked the control valve, and it was wide open. I opened the bypass valve around the control valve, but the supply-air temperature remained about the same.

After a little head scratching, I cut away the pipe insulation with my penknife and discovered the “design problem.” Although the contract documents indicated the steam supply pipe should be 3 in. in diameter, the area in the vicinity of the steam coil was congested, so the contractor reduced the diameter to 1¼ in. to match the control valve. I had the contractor replace the 1¼-in. pipe with the specified 3-in. pipe, reducing only at the inlet and outlet of the control valve. The unit has worked fine ever since.
Donald A. Raynor, PE
Kovacs, Whitney & Associates
Baltimore, Md.

Send “war stories” of 400 or fewer words to the attention of Scott Arnold, executive editor, at [email protected]. Authors are paid $50 per published war story.